

Dark star
It's only the first chapter, but I don't care much for it. Whipping the protagonist and a dead kid I can do without in my heroic fantasy. We don't even know how or why the kid died unless it was just to show Andra's empathy. It seems rushed. Personally, I leave slavery, abuse, and raping/pillaging to the distant past but I realize some authors cannot avoid it. On the other hand, the ceremony about the dragon pairing is cool. I wish you had more details about that. Although I'm a bit biased as I write YA D&D stories. I'm also slightly curious about the title. Who or what is the Bright Star? Anyway, your writing skills are excellent, I'm just averse to dark themes and situations.
Read the story nowD&D
Superb read. Out of all the D&D type stories I've reviewed this one is the best. The only thing I don't understand is why the dragon is scooping the bottom of the lake with its mouth when it can use its paws. Anyhow, excellent job! Keep it up.
Read the story nowHalf a story
Sadly, this is not the path to clarity, kiddo. What exactly are you trying to accomplish? I have many questions. Is there some mysterious or surprising connection between your DM and players and their character creations? Because there's no purpose in automatically revealing that they're not real. You've taken all the thrill and danger of playing a game and made it a moot point. Crumple up the character sheet and poof! that guy is dead. It's either a beginning D&D story or a Mazes and Monsters nightmare screenplay. I recommend you focus on one. Now, why pit them against measly one hit goblins only to kill them? That's a sign of a terrible DM. It's more pathetic that they couldn't even reach the Goblin King. And where the Hell is their armor? Oh, now they're killing a shopkeeper. That's different but not difficult. My big tip is that I strongly suggest that you start off with something shockingly unforgettable to grab the reader's attention. Anecdotally, my brother writes like his heroes don't have any purpose. I guess they're not interested in treasure or romance or fighting evil. They just watch the action around them. Oh, well, he has drain bamage. Okay, enough harping. I did enjoy their origin stories and I especially like the misfit elf and the little girl inside a Minotaur, probably because I'm a Taurus myself. Those names are also very inventive. Ahh, just thought of something. Perhaps the tabletop players are being played by some D&D Gods. That would be interesting. In conclusion, writing isn't easy. It should spark the reader's imagination, not bury it in mediocrity. Sometimes you have to write from your mind and not your heart. Keep your nose to the grindstone. Good luck.
Read the story nowApprentice Dragon
Okay, I've only read the first chapter but there isn't a dragon or an apprentice. It helps to start with the main protagonist of your story first. I could be wrong though because I'm no expert wordsmith. Personally, I don't care much for vampires, but I can give this a passing grade, although I was confused about the swishing tail initially. Before using other descriptors, I've been told to let the reader know who and what exactly the character is meant to be. The story seems reasonable, but it needs a slight edit. I wonder whether that skin and blood cloud is a real D&D spell. Also, I've never heard of a Bodak. Gruesome stuff, nevertheless. And what is his alignment? A Lizardman vampire isn't chaotic evil? He's powerful enough to take down a Cleric and yet wants a shaky alliance instead? I'm currently working on my third D&D story and it's a dungeon run. Not to toot my own horn, but I think it's purty epic. Check out Fear No Evil. Good luck in your future endeavors, Ely.
Read the story nowFear No Evil
This isn't much of a D&D story aside from a goblin raid, though I do like the new innovative environmental spell Acid Rain. The other spells are high-powered but don't have anything to do with known D&D magic. I think you're writing as a metaphysical wizard of some kind. Pun intended. It's as if the bat-kid were playing a game and got sucked into it. I've seen that movie. (Mazes and Monsters) I don't understand why he is a bat on Earth and on Gaia-- another Earth name. I'm thinking only after he mysteriously jumps through a portal would he would become a mutant bat. There's not enough information on why he would be a bat-like freak. There don't seem to be any benefits or consequences to his predicament. He gained echolocation, but he's not blind, so why or when would he ever use it? Same with wings and a tail. The main misgiving in being that he cannot fly and that he was bullied? Isn't everyone bullied in school? And if he was born a bat that leans into X-Men territory. This story seems to come from a personal standpoint as if you yourself were a young father and perhaps, were estranged from his own. I'm saying there's too much self-reflection Whether true or not, I like to write my D&D stories with more action/adventure moments rather than empty queries of why is my marriage falling apart or why doesn't my dad love me. I could also do without the bedchamber/chamber pot scene. I mean is it a D&D story or a Real Housewives episode? Okay, what's with the skewed priorities? A Queen that abandons her post to tell King Aiden that she understands him now? All women are crazy, right? Also, Aiden wants to abandon his adopted kingdom because the main antagonist razed it, and visiting his father is more important? I would argue that a king needs to fight for his country or he doesn't deserve to be a king. More importantly, I'm wondering why he's a king at all. A lot of assumptions are made here-- and I don't just mean in your writing style. If it's a monarchy then he could only be a royal consort, a type of pseudo king, I suppose. He wouldn't have the social standing or historic lore associated with royalty. So why would the kingdom bow to a youngster or respect him as much as the old king? Answer: They wouldn't. Of course, I could be wrong, but we know little about the history of the kingdom. I understand, it's an unfinished story. Overall, the supporting cast is cool, but your narration and verbiage are odd and sometimes awkward. I suggest Grammarly. Additionally, I recommend pronouns for your most important events or artifacts, or weapons. There's a magic box of import and yet the reader is thinking why the writer didn't give it a specific name. How about the Topsy Turvy Time Controller? I predict when Aiden has again traveled through the portal only a day has passed for his paternal unit, while years for himself. As I said, I think he was summoned into the game. Yeah. we've all seen that movie too. (Jumanji) No matter what, just keep on writing, R. Smith. Safe journeys, mate.
Read the story now