Strong opening. Good Action Desciption
"I do not know much about the Musketeers, but this was a great opening chapter in its own right. The way you blended d’Artagnan watching Athos and Athos’ own movement was excellent. It’s no easy feat to have an action scene that is being described by a character that is watching it and keep it from being nothing more than a list. The writing was very fluid and much like Athos’ sword, it flowed gracefully from one area to the next. I also really appreciated the parallel between d’Artagnan so closely watching Athos and in turn having Athos watch d’Artagnan. It created a good sense of a developing kinship between the two that they take the time to notice each other in such a way. You keep a good balance between describing the scene and not overworking with details. Excellent work and I wish you the best of luck with your further writing!"
- Valoración general
- Trama
- Estilo de escritura
- Gramática y puntuación
