Judge Review
"Ghost in the Roses
Author: Anna
Judge Review Winter 2021
At the time of this review I had completed six chapters to this long story. My congratulations in regards to submitting a fully completed book. Seeing authors show off their completed work shows initiative, passion and dedication to the craft.
In regards to the story you had set it to fantasy and drama. Reading into the first 6 chapters the story does exceed at both. In both the dramatic attack by a fellow knight into the dragons themselves the rode upon. The simple things that create the world passively such as the instance of the capricons or the angry dwarf aboard the train. Showing us the reader these instances of world building in a fantasy scenario was well thought out.
It seems the author was deliberate in reagards to plot development as well. From karma/ justice for the Noir fellow. Up to perhaps foreshadowing at the magical ceiling. There are key examples along this story that brushed into the plot itself seems to excell at.
Scene pacing however is one thing I would like to see slow down. The descriptions were great not too long, short, or over complicated. But the transition to a new scene was slightly jaring, I would include minor details to ease these transitions slightly.
My expectations of the story were subverted in all earnestly. Was expecting a harry potter clone but the distinctions are clear enough that this was not the case. The timing on certain things such as doing the ball first shook things up to keep an academy/school scene fresh.
The story itself read fine as well. However If I would make a suggestion, would be that the style of writing and verbiage would fit better for young adult readers. Clean out the cussing and replace with more wity remarks and tailor it closer to that market and I see this succeeding with a few more reads and edits. This is evident by the style of humor the author was looking to go for as well. Which helped liven up the atmosphere in the story. Assumptions aside should the story take a darker turn these moments of brevity among our characters would keep this fantasy from becoming a grim dark fantasy.
In conclusion I enjoyed your work and style in this story and would consider reading more in the future. Work on editing as a few mistakes were found, along with scene pacing and format. All in all great work.
--Rating--
Style: Style: Style in the written language unique to the author. How does your work stand out from the rest. 17/20
Theme: How did the theme of the story fit the genre it is trying to represent. How well did it succeed. 16/20.
Originality: Story elements and plot that leads to a great story. Tired tropes and cliché endings are a bore I do not adore. 15/20
Engagement: At what point was I captivated by the story. What makes me want to turn that page or put the book down. 19/20
Editing: How well your book is edited. 18/20
Total: 85/100"