

Lost me in chapter one
A long flashback that is meant to tell the story of why Zildjan walked the broken post-Apocalypse wastelands. The Good: Clear transitions. Consistent characters. Few grammar mistakes. The Meh: Anachronisms. Telling style. "Killing solves all problems." The Ugly: Initial anti-hook. Dialogue circles. No resolution. More on the Good: Transitions: It's very easy to tell what's a dream, read from a computer screen, dialogue, and narrative. Characters: There are very few, all serve a clear purpose to the narrative and remain consistent from start to finish. Grammar: The few mistakes I noticed could easily be cleared up with simple proofread techniques. The 'Meh' are generally things that don't appeal to me personally, i.e. nothing actionable unless they appear in multiple reviews. Anachronisms: Entry blurb states that the year is 3450 but the content of the story makes it seem a generation or two removed from a 20 year-long near total Apocalypse that started in 2040. Style: Long info-dumps. Telling descriptions that mean that the narrator talks directly to the reader (although this was made much more tolerable because we learn in chapter 1 that the MC is telling his story to someone else). Death as a Resolution: Kill everything just doesn't appeal to me as a way to solve *all* conflicts - even if it is justified by the story's circumstances. 'The Ugly' are Issues that, IMO, are significant flaws within the story. The Hook - Chapter 1 is meant to draw the reader in, inform us of the central conflict, and get us invested in the characters. There are unclear descriptions, talking dead, Point-of-view hopping, and a disconnected voice. Which means that, rather than being hooked into the story, I seriously considered stopping with chapter 1. Dialogue Circles - Several conversations rambled on and on and were as unconvincing and directionless as they were long. Resolution: There's no clear ending to this story, just the promise of more. There's a little bit of disconnect between what's promised in the blurb and chapter 1 and what happens in the story. My first read through of chapter one was confusing - but it made a little more sense after getting through the rest of the story (I'll highlight and send some specific things that make no sense no matter how I read them). I have to conclude that chapter 1 is meant to start a series of stories, not just the one told in this book. Keep writing, which is to say, Edit, Edit, Edit! You have a talent for telling stories that will only grow stronger the more you write and polish what you write.
Read the story nowWe all know what the road to hell is paved with...
Overall, an interesting short story. The Good: Clear premise and succinct narrative. Thought provoking. The Meh: Odd descriptions, vague ending. The Ugly: Obvious head-hop without transition in the second part. I'll highlight and send specific feedback, but the best thing I can really say about this story is I stopped for a moment and said, "Man, it really sucks to be that guy." Which means you created reader sympathy which is never a bad thing. Within my highlighted responses you'll see suggestions for showing rather than telling, sentences that didn't make sense, where the head hopping happened without transition, and suggestions for tightening up the prose. Overall, well done! Keep up with your writing!
Read the story nowUnedited Demonic Paladin Erotica
A quick, easy read featuring R.A. Salvatore style combat and a basic exploration of the difference between love, possessiveness, and desire. The Good: 90% of what's on the page is directly pertinent to the story. Interesting way to contrast seemingly opposing viewpoints. The Meh: There's no real resolution. Fairly predictable plot. The Ugly: Technical writing skills. First: Proofread, Edit, Proofread, and then Edit again. Read sentences out loud. Copy and paste individual sentences into blank documents and pick them apart for tone, grammar, punctuation, etc... I lost track of the number of sentences with missing, misused, or redundant words. The story length could probably be halved just by eliminating redundancies. Second: If you're going to describe that much combat, choreograph. Have friends act it out or act it out yourself. Many of the detailed descriptions fail based on logic, physics, and tactics. One example that hits all three: The fight with the Lord Commander. Even without increased speed and strength, he was described as easily twice her size and weight; there's no way she's going to knock him on his back while he's braced unless he threw the fight - which he cannot do logically. So her tactic would be to unbalance him first, and then knock him on his back. Tactics he would know to expect since he's (probably) watched the whole of her training. Finally, you have a long, redundant exploration of a complicated, emotional topic without a resolution. Unless, of course, you're saying that the only way to reconcile misunderstandings about love and lust involve sexual bonding and slavery. Which, I don't think you do, mainly because the first external threat to that solution tore it apart almost instantly. Last thoughts: You tell an engaging and detailed story - I particularly appreciated that you didn't burden me with tons of unnecessary backstory. Hone your craft just a little bit and there's no reason why you can't deliver five star epics.
Read the story now