All's Fair in Love and Quidditch
All's fair in love and quiddich

"It was a cool and funny fanfiction. However, it is mentioned in "Quiddich through the ages" that summoning the snitch is considered a foul. Also, I'm surprised that no on heard him summoning the snitch since he yelled. Overall, it amazing."

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?
All's fair in love and quiddich

"It was a cool and funny fanfiction. However, it is mentioned in "Quiddich through the ages" that summoning the snitch is considered a foul. Also, I'm surprised that no on heard him summoning the snitch since he yelled. Overall, it amazing."

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?

4Eirlys

0 capítulos leídos

4Eirlys

"I really liked your story, and to be honest I thought it was pretty good, espiecally with the suspense. But, the only problem I have with it.... What was the poiint in Accioing the snitch? I get its a big deal and against the rules ad everything, but to be honest it seems like such a waste."

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?
Title (optional...but not really)

"This was fantastic! I was kept waiting, anticipating what it was that James was going to do. I was a little concerned because I thought you meant James Potter, not James S. Potter, but I eventually made the connection. I think the only thing that is lacking here is Ginny's role. She grew up with six older brothers; she played on the Gryffindor team, and then moved on to play for England. If James was going to seriously talk Quidditch to anyone, I think it would have been his mother. Or, at the very least, she should not have had a side-line, soccer mom sort of role. That was the only fault I found in this. Other than that, brilliantly done!"

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?

Alexannah

0 capítulos leídos

Funny!

"Methinks they'll be updating the Hogwarts Quidditch rules ... hehe. Great idea. It made me laugh. I can just picture Harry struggling not to laugh while he thinks "Why did I never think of that?" It certainly beat his own record of five minutes. Loved it, cool little fic!"

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?

Soph

0 capítulos leídos

Priceless!

"I love your writing style, it flows effortlessly. Very pleasant to read :) I have to read more to leave a more detailed review *hint hint*"

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?

persevera

0 capítulos leídos

Review

"I like the way you built the suspense for what could James be planning, with a little personal history and his ongoing thoughts that it would be epic. Hard to believe that no one ever thought of that trick, particularly Slytherins, or that it hadn't already been addressed in snitch development, but, as someone wrote, it will be now. Fun story"

  • Valoración general
  • Trama
  • Estilo de escritura
  • Gramática y puntuación
¿Te ha resultado útil esta reseña?