

Honestly... brilliant!
I've loved reading this book! The dynamic between the main characters is spot on, and the way you've written them makes it very easy for the reader to become invested in their story. The banter between them is fantastic. It feels natural and effortless and I love Sofia's quick wit! The little details of their interactions, like him calling her 'pretty girl' and her calling him 'Bobby', really bring their connection to life. Those moments made them feel very real, and I often found myself smiling along with them while reading. I also really like the character growth for these characters. Watching her develop throughout the story has been very satisfying, and Rob being smitten with her adds such a great dynamic to their relationship. I'm a big fan of third-person narration, so this style made it very easy for me to sink into the story. Because I was so absorbed in the book and enjoying the characters so much, I didn't notice any issues with grammar or punctuation while reading. Overall, this has been a brilliant read and you've done a great job bringing these characters and their story to life. Well done! If you ever have the time, I'm currently looking for some reviews on a romance I'm working on called Wildflowers at Willowbrook, so I'd love to hear your thoughts if that's something you'd be interested in reading.
Read the story nowPromising start...
I really enjoyed reading the first few chapters of your book. It's a strong concept and an interesting idea for a story. I particularly connect with books that include biblical references, and themes involving angels and demons are always something that captures my interest, so this immediately drew me in. The premise has a lot of potential and I found the story engaging so far. I also enjoyed Ravenna as a character. Interestingly, while I'm usually not a big fan of first-person narration, I actually quite liked Ravenna's voice when it was written from her perspective. It felt natural for her character and helped bring her personality through. One small piece of feedback would be regarding the first part of the prologue written in first person. Most of the chapter is written in third person, so personally I think it might read more smoothly if it stayed consistent in third person throughout this chapter. I generally find switching between first and third within the same section a little jarring, though I appreciate that this can be a stylistic choice. There are also a few minor grammar points that could be tidied up, but nothing major that affected my understanding of the story. I did notice quite a heavy use of em dashes in places where commas might work just as well. That's very much a personal preference though, as some readers enjoy that style. One question I had while reading: will there be other character perspectives later in the book? I noticed each chapter currently states that it's from Ravenna's POV. Once a character's perspective has been established, you may not necessarily need to repeat it each chapter unless you're planning to introduce additional viewpoints later on. Overall, I think this story has a lot of potential. Even with only five chapters so far, the premise is compelling and I'd definitely be interested in reading more to see where the story goes. It's a great foundation for what could become a really engaging book. Also, if you happen to enjoy romance and have the time, I'm currently looking for readers and feedback on a book I've written called Wildflowers in Willowbrook. No pressure at all, but if that's something you might be interested in, I'd love to hear your thoughts.
Read the story nowInteresting read...
I do like a good wolf book and yours doesn't disappoint! You have a really great way of describing your characters - it's clear and easily visualised. The same can be said with the action, it's interesting and you can keep the pace going very well. You have beautifully laid out your paragraphs, shorter ones work really well with your story. I love the chapter names! The only major thing I find that could be worked on is the dialog. There are times when it feels slightly robotic and 2D. However, this improves a lot from chapter 3. From that point, it's a lot easier to read. There are the odd grammar mistakes but nothing too major and can easily be sorted. Otherwise, a really fantastic book and I look forward to reading more!
Read the story nowA lovely start...
This is not typically the type of book that I would usually read but I enjoyed it very much. You have a really interesting plot and I would like to see how the rest of the book plays out. Is this your first book? Because you have a lot of potential as a writer here, really great ideas and are good at moving the plot forward. You have clearly put a lot of thought and effort into your work - so really well done! Just some tips for improvement: 1) When writing a book with multiple voices it's best to stick to third person. First person is absolutely perfect when there is one voice but it can get really confusing when you're using first person with multiple characters. As the book progresses, it changes from first to third person and back again in multiple places in the same chapter - this can be very confusing for the reader. I think it's a great idea to change prospective as this can give you a great insight to another character. However, I would stick to one point of view per chapter (meaning either first or third, not both). If you prefer first person, I would only use it for one character and third for every other character. 2) When you wrote about Athena's mum's age. It stated she was "the head scientist at 29". Do you mean she is 29 or she achieved head scientist at 29? This needs to be clearer as I wasn't sure, the latter being more plausible, 3) There are some grammar and punctuation errors, nothing too major. 4) Try to structure your descriptions with more visual details to show the reader what is happening. This is something that will come with time. You have the base of the story so far, you just need some things fleshing out. Overall, a really fantastic start! Keep up the hard work! I hope I helped x
Read the story nowBeautifully written...
This was such an enjoyable read! I thought the pace of the plot is absolutely spot on, you are giving the reader a small taster of the characters and leaving us wanting so much more! That is the perfect way to write a book. You want the reader to connect with your characters! You want the reader to be so invested in your story that it keeps them up at night, and saying to themselves "Just one more chapter." That is how I am seeing your book. Addictive. Completely and utterly wonderful. Your writing style is awe-inspiring, you give the right amount of description and dialog. Your work is so beautifully written that I got caught up in your story. So much so, that I didn't notice any punctuation or grammar errors. I can clearly see how much hard work you've put into this - so please keep up the excellent work! This is without a doubt publishing worthy, so I wish you the best of luck xx
Read the story nowFantastic
Wow, I enjoyed reading the first couple of chapters you have. I have to say that your book pulled me in from the very first couple of sentences - that's something difficult to master, so really well done. I happen to really love Halloween, so that first paragraph was really great - until your character revealed she didn't like Halloween and my heart completely went out to her! Speaking of Halloween, it always reminds me of A Nightmare Before Christmas and I spent the first half of chapter 1 singing "This is Halloween". Your MC reminding me slightly of Jack. Ha! I love your furry friend, Cleo. I always love it when there is an animal with really good characteristic (her impatience), and you did this really well. Just a couple of tips: 1) I would recommend structuring your paragraphs and fine tuning it for the story to flow better, 2) Using a new line for dialog, and 3) clear indication that your prospective has changed in a new chapter. I didn't realise until a few lines down that it had changed. Overall, really great start and look forward to reading updates - I'm very interested to know what is up with the house!
Read the story nowFantastic start...
Wow, you really have a great opener here. I enjoyed reading the first few chapters that you have and I am excited to see what will happen next. I love the chapter titles, it's something I've always wanted to do in my work but never managed to do it. I like the characters a lot, especially the sarcasm they bring to the table. This helped me relate to the characters easier - I have a dark sense of humour. I very much loved the reference at the bottom of the third chapter. It made me laugh. However, the winky face is grammatically incorrect. In this instance, you can break up a line of speech to show an action by saying something like: "I can paint you like a French girl, Jack," He winked suggestively. "Or should I say Jake?" Just a couple of tips for improvement would be: 1) The descriptions need a little fine tuning to improve the flow and pace of the story. 2) There are some grammar errors with capitalisation, full stops and commas in the wrong places instead of stand alone sentences. However, other than that, I think you have real potential for this book and I would be interested to read any further updates. I hope I helped x
Read the story nowGood start
This is a really great first chapter, interesting and engaging. I look forward to reading more :)
Read the story nowWow
I know you only have 2 chapters so far but I thought I would write a quick review now. Your prologue seriously gripped me - it's been written so brilliantly! It can be difficult for me to get into a new book but the pace flowed so smoothly that I was able to empathise with your character from the beginning. This in turn, makes me want to read more. I loved chapter 1 too and I will follow your book for updates. Katie xx
Read the story nowA truly wonderful read
You have written a really fantastic book! I was hooked from the first chapter and I couldn't stop reading until I finished. It can be quite difficult for me to get into a new book but your writing style is brilliant! You're really good at keeping a steady pace, keeping the plot interesting. I love how you name each chapter - I think it's a lovely extra detail. Quite frankly, I need more! Katie xx
Read the story now